Host Brett
Administrator 
the control freak
Posts: 500 
|
Post by Host Brett on Sept 10, 2011 22:13:29 GMT -5
Judging criteria: - Effectiveness: Could this function as an actual S.O.S. signal? (10 points)
- Neatness: Is it put together well? Or is it messy? (10 points)
- Creativity/Use of items: How creative you guys are! Is your design smart and interesting or is it something the world's most boring three year old could come up with? (10 points)
- Teamwork: More points if you guys all work together on this, less if someone does it all for you. Not everyone is a master at photoshop, but if you contribute creative ideas you'll get a higher score. (10 points)
- Instructions. Did you follow all the rules? Did you use an item too many times? (10 points)
PWs: We need at least 2 of you to judge both tribe's submissions. You can read the rules here: and see their work in the threads posted below each submission. You'll be grading them on a scale of 1-10 in the 5 criteria. |
|
|
|
Post by John Carroll on Sept 11, 2011 3:36:52 GMT -5
I think the second one is WAY better
|
|
Host Lex
Administrator
;D
The Bastard
Posts: 780
|
Post by Host Lex on Sept 11, 2011 11:38:36 GMT -5
Gorgita
- Effectiveness: 8
- Neatness: 9
- Creativity/Use of items: 7
- Teamwork: 8
- Instructions: 7
= 39
Bangalang
- Effectiveness: 8
- Neatness: 6
- Creativity/Use of items: 6
- Teamwork: 5
- Instructions: 8
= 33
|
|
|
|
Post by Hunter Ellis on Sept 11, 2011 13:05:22 GMT -5
Gorgita
- Effectiveness: 8
- Neatness: 9
- Creativity/Use of items: 8
- Teamwork: 9
- Instructions: 8
= 42
Bangalang
- Effectiveness: 7
- Neatness: 6
- Creativity/Use of items: 7
- Teamwork: 7
- Instructions: 8
= 35
|
|
|
|
Post by Rupert Boneham on Sept 11, 2011 13:35:43 GMT -5
Gorgita
Effectiveness: 5
Didn't do much for me, it felt kind of random with some items providing no real purpose
Neatness: 7
I guess it was fairly neat and simple, but could've had more going for it
Creativity/Use of Items: 8
Used a variety of items, some were kind of random like the Japanese flag,, but at least they stayed within the limits
Teamwork: 9
I see they all pitched in somehow
Instructions: 7
They followed the basic instructions for the scenario
Total=36
Bangalang
Effectiveness: 8
Sign is effective, SOS could be a bit neater and thus lost some points on that
Neatness: 6
Not the greatest, still don't know what the blue thing is
Creativity/Use of Items: 7
Used the items they needed from the list
Teamwork: 8
I see people participated and some even added to the photo
Instructions: 9
They followed the instructions well, not much complaint here
Total= 38
|
|
Host Brett
Administrator
the control freak
Posts: 500
|
Post by Host Brett on Sept 11, 2011 15:14:13 GMT -5
GORGITA
- Effectiveness:9
- Neatness: 9
- Creativity/Use of items: 6
- Teamwork: 6
- Instructions. 7
Total: 37
BANGALANG
- Effectiveness: 7
- Neatness: 7
- Creativity/Use of items: 7
- Teamwork: 9
- Instructions. 6 (used less items than they chose)
Total: 36
|
|
